Charting your project
Buying a boat

Performance or Comfort: choosing your catamaran

When choosing a catamaran, buyers must weigh three factors — performance, comfort and price. Here's how recent trends in the industry are reshaping that trade-off.

12 September 2018 ·David Allouch · 2 min read

Performance and comfort: is there a trade-off?

When selecting a catamaran, prospective buyers must weigh three key considerations: performance, comfort, and price. Recent construction trends in the catamaran industry shed light on these trade-offs.

Outremer announced participation of three boat owners in the Route du Rhum ocean race. Fountaine Pajot, the second-largest catamaran manufacturer, launched a new range including the sell-out Astrea 42, with a resolutely sporty look.

Despite this activity, recent years witnessed disappearance of notable performance brands: Catana shifted focus to cruising Bali models, while Looping and Freydis production nearly ceased.

So what is the future of the performance catamaran?

For multihulls, the fundamental equation remains straightforward: to go faster you need a better sail area to weight ratio and a reduced wetted surface. Over two decades, this principle produced impressive, fast vessels still popular in pre-owned markets: Looping, Freydis, Outremer, and Catana.

Meanwhile, large series cruising catamaran owners sometimes felt like caravan owners.

Gradually, evidence emerged about blue water cruiser priorities: in a long-distance cruising scenario, one spends much more time at anchor than sailing.

Comfort is important

Series catamaran builders equipped vessels with indispensable amenities: washing machines, freezers, water makers, air conditioning…

This widened distinctions between sailing purists like Francis Joyon's TS50 — capable of doing 400nm in 24 hours — and most sailors prioritizing comfort at the cost of such impressive performance.

Financial crises in 2000 and 2008 forced many boatyards into bankruptcy. Survivors invested in improved technology and techniques. The performance equation remained unchanged, but market response shifted: to go fast, one no longer needs to sacrifice on comfort, but instead must invest in design and technology. Sustaining this investment required selling boats internationally, accessible only to the largest boatyards employing premier architects like VPLP and Berret-Racoupeau, high-tech facilities, and extensive commercial networks.

Achieving speed without sacrificing comfort demands serious investment: detailed architecture, high-tech materials (carbon), expensive components (lithium batteries). Notable examples include the Marsaudon TS5 and Outremer 4X.

For the sailor, the choice is no longer between comfort and performance, but rather price and performance …

Boatyards like Fountaine Pajot performed well balancing comfort with performance. They offer expected comfort with increasing performance orientation: the new 45 announced by the yard at the recent Cannes Boat Show has a weight/sail ratio of 8.75 m2 per tonne and hulls with 10% less resistance compared with her predecessor, the Helia 44 — enough to cross oceans at 9/10 knots and take some fun surfs.

The Outremer 4X delivers superior speed while offering identical livable space as the Astrea 42, but costs almost double — it's your choice to make!

Planning something similar?

Tell us where you want to sail, when, and with whom. We will come back with a route, a shortlist of boats and a realistic budget.

Keep reading
French Polynesia

Polynesia is best seen from the water.

Five archipelagos, 118 islands and enough lagoons to cruise for years without anchoring twice in the same place. Every boat we sell, rent and look after is there to help you enjoy them.

Moorea
Blacktip reef, Tetiaroa
Anchorage, Marquesas
Motu and lagoon, Tikehau

Stay with your project

A few emails a year: boats arriving in Polynesia, brokerage listings before they go public, passage notes and news of the season.